The Real Reason Californians and New Yorkers Are Moving to Florida — And It's Not the Weather

BLOG POST - 8.12.2026

The Real Reason Californians and New Yorkers Are Moving to Florida — And It's Not the Weather Every week I talk to a buyer relocating here from California, New York, or Massachusetts. Ask them why, and most will mention the beaches, the lack of a state income tax, or wanting to escape another humid summer up north. But when you sit down and actually run the numbers with them, the tax math is almost always the bigger driver — not the palm trees.

A recent Wall Street Journal analysis put real numbers behind what buyer's agents like me see anecdotally every day. The findings are striking enough that I think every high earner considering a move — or sitting on the fence about one — should see them.

What the Numbers Actually Say For a couple earning $5 million a year, the WSJ analysis found that in California or New York City, they keep about 46 cents of every additional dollar they earn after federal, state, and local taxes.

Move that same couple to Florida, and they keep 60 cents of every additional dollar — no state income tax, no city tax, nothing.

That's not a rounding error. It's roughly a 30% effective raise, without a new job, a promotion, or a single extra hour of work. Just a change of address.

It Could Get Bigger Two things on the horizon make this gap more likely to widen than shrink:

The Social Security payroll cap. There's a growing bipartisan push in Congress to lift the cap on income subject to Social Security payroll taxes — a proposal backed by Senators Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren, and notably, Ohio Republican Senator Bernie Moreno as well. If that cap comes off, the same $5M couple's effective raise for relocating to Florida jumps from 30% to 41%.

California's wealth tax ballot measure. This November, California voters will consider a ballot measure taxing net worth over $1 billion. Even for buyers who aren't anywhere near that threshold personally, measures like this tend to signal where a state's tax policy is headed — and they're accelerating decisions that were already in motion. High earners aren't waiting to see how it plays out; many are choosing to make a move now rather than later.

Why This Matters More Than People Realize Most people underestimate how much this compounds. A 30-41% effective raise on ordinary income, sustained over years, isn't a one-time bonus — it's a permanent shift in take-home pay that compounds through investments, real estate, and retirement savings. For a lot of the buyers I work with, the tax savings alone can justify a home purchase that would otherwise feel like a stretch.

This is also why timing conversations like "should we buy now or wait" often miss the bigger picture. The tax differential is happening regardless of mortgage rates or the local housing cycle. Every year spent in a high-tax state is a year of that differential left on the table.

Why This Is Exactly Why I Do What I Do Here's the part that doesn't get talked about enough: when someone is making a decision this consequential — moving a family, a business, or a portfolio across the country largely for tax reasons — they usually don't have a local network to vet the deal for them. They don't know which neighborhoods are overpriced, which listing agents are also representing the seller's interests, or where the next flood zone remapping might hit.

That's the gap I fill. As an exclusive buyer's agent in St. Pete, I represent the buyer only — never the seller, never both sides of a transaction. That distinction matters most precisely when you're relocating from out of state and need someone whose only job is looking out for you.

If You're Thinking About It If you or someone you know is weighing a move to the Tampa Bay area — whether it's driven by taxes, lifestyle, or both — let's talk before you start touring homes. A short conversation up front can save you from a lot of costly missteps later.

Explore Jon Kelly St. Pete

Jon Kelly Exclusive Buyer Representation, St. Petersburg, Florida

Source: WSJ analysis. This post is for informational purposes only and is not tax or financial advice — consult a qualified tax professional for guidance specific to your situation.